Nestled in the scenic town of Mentone, Alabama, The Hatter Café is a whimsical wonderland that invites visitors to step into a world inspired by Lewis Carroll’s classic tale, Alice in Wonderland. Owned and operated by Roger and Pamela Wald, this delightful café has become a beloved destination for those seeking a unique dining experience, southern hospitality and a dash of nostalgia. We recently caught up with the pair on the Unexpected Adventures in North Alabama Podcast, so listen to the latest episode about their story and read on about why this small business is taking North Alabama by storm.
Listen to the Unexpected Adventures in North Alabama podcast episode:
A Dreamy Beginning
The story of The Hatter Café began not with a grand business plan, but with a serendipitous road trip. Pamela, an occupational therapist by trade, and her husband Roger, found themselves captivated by the charm of Mentone during a visit to the world's longest yard sale which took them through the area. Originally from Florida, the couple was taken by the town’s breathtaking natural beauty and the warm welcome of its residents. What started as a casual visit turned into a life-changing decision; within a month, they had purchased a house in Mentone, feeling an undeniable pull to make it their home.
The café’s Alice in Wonderland theme was born from Pamela’s creative vision, which initially sparked while planning a baby shower. Her fascination with the whimsical and nostalgic elements of the story made it the perfect theme for a café meant to be a gathering place filled with joy and memories.
A Cozy Café with Character
The Hatter Café isn’t just a place to grab a bite—it’s an experience. Located in a house built in the 1950s, the café has a rich history that adds to its charm. The building has previously served as an artist's gallery, a gift shop, and even a restaurant, making it a perfect canvas for Pamela’s imaginative decor.
Inside, guests are greeted with a cozy, vintage ambiance where every detail has been thoughtfully curated. From the delicate china to chandeliers made from teacups and antique hats, the décor at The Hatter Café feels like stepping into a whimsical time capsule. The attention to detail extends to the walls, where end tables have been repurposed as unique shelves for displaying teacups and other curiosities.
Southern Comfort with a Twist
The menu at The Hatter Café is a delightful fusion of classic Southern comfort food with a creative twist that nods to its Alice in Wonderland inspiration. Roger, who modestly refers to himself as a good home cook, takes pride in preparing dishes from scratch, using family recipes and fresh ingredients.
One of the standout items is the Meatloaf Pie, where seasoned potatoes, corn, cheddar cheese and bacon are baked inside a savory meatloaf crust—a fun and hearty take on a traditional dish. Another favorite is the Hot Brown, an open-faced smoked turkey sandwich served on homemade bread, topped with a rich Mornay sauce, and baked to perfection.
For those looking for something lighter, the café offers refreshing salads like the Pear and Gorgonzola Salad or the Chicken Salad Sandwich, which is served on homemade cinnamon raisin bread and topped with candied pecans. And let’s not forget the Cheshire Meow, a grilled cheese sandwich featuring Havarti cheese, pear, and fig jam—sure to satisfy both your taste buds and your sense of whimsy.
Sweet Treats and Afternoon Tea
No visit to The Hatter Café would be complete without indulging in one of their decadent desserts. The café's bakery offers a range of southern favorites like peach cobbler, pecan cobbler, and cinnamon raisin bread pudding with custard cream sauce. The Ooey Gooey Chocolate Cake is a must-try for chocolate lovers, described as a moist, rich treat drizzled with chocolate and dusted with powdered sugar.
The café also offers a traditional afternoon tea service, complete with tiered trays of sandwiches, scones, biscuits, specialty bread and desserts. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a leisurely afternoon, the tea service at The Hatter Café is a charming experience that transports you to another time and place.
A Destination Worth the Drive
Despite its quaint, off-the-beaten-path location, The Hatter Café has attracted visitors from all over the world. Whether they’re driving up from nearby cities like Huntsville and Birmingham or traveling from as far away as India, Dubai or Australia, guests are drawn to the café’s unique charm and the promise of creating special memories.
The Hatter Café’s popularity has grown largely through word of mouth and social media, with fans sharing their experiences and encouraging others to visit. It’s not just the food and atmosphere that keep people coming back; it’s the sense of community and the warm, welcoming vibe that Roger and Pamela have cultivated. The couple’s passion for creating a space where people can gather, relax, and enjoy themselves is evident in every aspect of the café.
Stay a While at The Hatter Country Inn
For those who want to extend their visit, The Hatter Café also offers cozy accommodations at The Hatter Country Inn, located on the same property. The inn features two beautifully decorated rooms—the Mentone Room and the Royal Room—each with its own ensuite bathroom and private deck with a Jacuzzi. Guests at the inn enjoy a complimentary breakfast from the café’s menu, making it the perfect getaway for a weekend of relaxation and exploration.
Visit The Hatter Café
Whether you’re a local or a traveler passing through, The Hatter Café is a must-visit destination in North Alabama. Its whimsical atmosphere, delicious food, and heartfelt hospitality make it a place where memories are made. So, if you find yourself in the mountains of Mentone, follow the white rabbit to The Hatter Café—you’ll be glad you did.
For more information and to plan your visit, check out The Hatter Café’s website or follow them on Facebook. And remember, in the words from the book, “The secret, Alice, is to surround yourself with people who make your heart smile.” At The Hatter Café, you’ll do just that.
